• Turkey and the EU: Old Routine and New Tensions

    Posted by: Marc Pierini November 27, 2015

    Since Turkey started accession negotiations with the EU in 2005, a relatively predictable dialogue has unfolded about chapters, which are either opened or blocked, and political criteria, which are fulfilled either sufficiently or less so. Recently, discussions also took place on modernizing the EU-Turkey Customs Union, implementing visa liberalization, and readmitting irregular migrants. As slow or frustrating as it was at times, this comfortable routine remained immune from hard politics.

    EU-Turkey relations are now in a different era. The “new Turkey”—the term used by the country’s president after successive presidential and legislative elections—finds itself in a multipronged conflictual situation of prime importance to the EU over the war in Syria, the self-proclaimed Islamic State, and the refugee crisis. At the same time, Ankara is caught in rather tense interactions with the United States over U.S. support for Syrian Kurdish forces and with Russia following Turkey’s downing of a Russian military aircraft on November 24.

    On top of their old routine, the EU and Turkey now have much more daunting issues on their plates: Do they work together against the Islamic State, and do they see the refugee crisis as a joint challenge?

    At a summit in Brussels on November 29, the two sides are expected to agree on an EU-Turkey refugee action plan. The agreement will provide financial support for refugees in Turkey in the form of humanitarian support, education, and job creation in exchange for better control of human traffickers. The deal will also include a positive EU impulse to reenergize Turkey’s accession negotiations and accelerate visa facilitation talks, both to be implemented within the existing framework of strict conditionality. Observers should look carefully: the EU will not lower its standards on the rule of law, a domain in which Turkey has been hugely backsliding in the past two years, including this week.

    While the refugee action plan might just look like money for concessions, the underlying issue is the free hand enjoyed by traffickers operating in broad daylight on the Aegean coast. This is an enormous business of some €1 billion ($1.1 billion) a year: by the end of 2015, over 700,000 asylum seekers, mostly Syrians, Afghans, and Pakistanis, will have crossed from Turkey to Greece, each paying an average of €1,000–1,500 (a very conservative estimate) to traffickers on Turkey’s coastline. Getting this shameful and deadly racket under control is now the key issue.

    Meanwhile, the focus of EU politics—and therefore of discussions with Turkey—has shifted dramatically toward Islamic State terrorism. Despite an optimistic Western narrative, the Islamist group is resilient and expanding in Sinai and Libya. It was recently able to cause some 500 deaths in thirty-five days in Turkey, the Middle East, and Western Europe. Islamic State operatives have challenged the police in France and Belgium, and inquiries have revealed connections between the perpetrators of recent killings and jihadists moving to and from Syria via Turkey.

    From a counterterrorism standpoint, the recent spate of coordinated terrorist attacks is a quantum leap. From a European political standpoint, it is an earthquake.

    Although many observers see an emerging anti–Islamic State coalition involving Russia, the United States, and France, this will translate into little more than minimal military cooperation to avoid accidental mishaps. This is not overly surprising because Russia’s objectives—first rescuing Syrian President Bashar al-Assad from the brink of deposal, then going after the Islamic State—differ substantially from the aims of the U.S.-led coalition.

    The November 15–16 G20 meeting in Antalya showed that the United States, Europe, and Russia now have a common objective: stopping the well-documented flow of smuggled oil from Islamic State–controlled territory into Turkey. Russia claims that it has destroyed 500 oil tankers in Islamic State–held territory, while the United States said it had wiped out some 280. The West and Russia see severing one of the Islamic State’s main financial resources as a critical issue. Despite Ankara’s denials, Turkey is now openly criticized for its lack of action on the issue. Also, the transit of jihadists via Turkey, despite some improvements, remains a major source of concern, especially for France and Belgium.

    Turkey’s priority objectives in Syria—the fall of the Assad regime, the establishment of a safe zone or no-fly zone, and the containment of the Syrian Kurds—have long been out of reach. The fate of Assad has become a secondary priority for the West, at least in the short term. U.S. President Barack Obama has publicly rejected the idea of a safe zone. And the Syrian Kurds have become essential partners for the United States, which has provided them with close air support and special forces on the ground, and won the political endorsement of Russian President Vladimir Putin in his speech to the UN General Assembly on September 28.

    The November 13 Paris attacks and the refugee crisis are true game changers. Despite the oddity of the Syrian chessboard, the Islamic State has now become a common target for the United States, Europe, and Russia. As a result, Turkey’s ambivalent narrative on the Islamist group and its benign neglect on refugee traffickers are under close scrutiny.

    Seen from Paris or Washington, there is a need for a thorough clarification of Turkey’s policy on Syria. Pro-Western political narratives from the Turkish leadership will not suffice at a time when smothering the Islamic State has become an overwhelming political priority for Western powers.

    The despicable carnage in the heart of Turkey’s capital on October 10, when two bombs killed over 100 people, should be seen as a turning point—just as the downing of a Russian airliner over the Sinai on October 31 or the Paris massacres, events that led policies to be readjusted accordingly. Despite Ankara’s right to protect its sovereignty, the tragic incident between the Russian and Turkish air forces on November 24 is a serious complicating factor.

    As the Islamic State wages a brutal war in Europe, with command centers in Syria, and the refugee crisis takes on a critical societal dimension, Turkey’s strategic foreign policy choices are more pivotal than ever. On November 29 in Brussels, the words and unequivocal commitments of Turkey—a NATO member and an EU candidate country—will be closely scrutinized.


  • Letter From Baku

    Posted by: Emin Milli Friday, November 27, 2015

    The EU’s problem in Azerbaijan is that it lacks leverage. Smart and targeted sanctions against certain government figures would help.

  • NATO’s Powerlessness Over Syria and Refugees

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Thursday, November 26, 2015

    The Atlantic alliance has no strategy to confront the so-called Islamic State or to deal with Russia’s growing presence in the Mediterranean.

  • Judy Asks: Does Europe Have a Security Problem?

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Wednesday, November 25, 2015

    Every week, a selection of leading experts answer a new question from Judy Dempsey on the foreign and security policy challenges shaping Europe’s role in the world.

  • The Unbearable Lightness of European Defense

    Posted by: Daniel Keohane Tuesday, November 24, 2015 2

    Despite recent terrorist attacks by the so-called Islamic State, EU governments are unlikely to commit to deeper European military cooperation.

  • Angela Merkel’s Second Decade

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Monday, November 23, 2015

    The German chancellor has the chance to change Europe and the transatlantic relationship. She should seize it.

  • Letter From Minsk

    Posted by: Andrei Yahorau Friday, November 20, 2015 1

    If the EU wants a reliable partner in Belarus, the country must be transformed into a more democratic state. Only the Belarusian people can achieve this transformation.

  • The Lure of Returning to Business as Usual With Russia

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Thursday, November 19, 2015 1

    Ukraine should not be used as a pawn in Western cooperation with Russia in fighting the so-called Islamic State.

  • Toward a European Neighborhood Realpolitik?

    Posted by: Stefan Lehne Thursday, November 19, 2015

    The EU’s recent review of its European Neighborhood Policy offers a more realistic and practical approach to the union’s relations with its neighbors.

  • Judy Asks: Can Europe Defeat the Islamic State?

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Wednesday, November 18, 2015 3

    Every week, a selection of leading experts answer a new question from Judy Dempsey on the foreign and security policy challenges shaping Europe’s role in the world.

  • Europe’s Foreign Policy Reaction to the Paris Attacks? Noise

    Posted by: Jan Techau Tuesday, November 17, 2015 4

    For the military protection of their interests, Europeans still rely on the Americans to come to their aid. The November 13 Paris attacks are unlikely to change that.

  • After the Paris Attacks: The Open Society and Its Enemies

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Monday, November 16, 2015 5

    The murder of many civilians in Paris must not erode Europe’s open society.

  • Letter From Yerevan

    Posted by: Mikayel Zolyan Friday, November 13, 2015

    Armenia needs to find its own voice on foreign policy and ensure that its international partnerships do not limit the country’s ability to make sovereign decisions.

  • Cameron Throws Down the Gauntlet to (a Weak) Europe

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Thursday, November 12, 2015 2

    Britain’s prime minister has set out the terms for his country remaining in the EU. Some EU member states might actually welcome them.

  • Five Regional Assessments of the Refugee Crisis

    Posted by: Stefan Lehne, Marc Pierini, Gwendolyn Sasse, Sinan Ülgen, Pierre Vimont Tuesday, November 10, 2015 1

    Five Carnegie Europe scholars discuss how the migration and refugee crisis is affecting different parts of the globe.

  • Europe’s Problem With Vision

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Monday, November 09, 2015 4

    European leaders should forget about wanting vision. Instead, they need to discover strategy.

  • Letter From Kiev

    Posted by: Mikhail Minakov Friday, November 06, 2015 8

    There is a serious mismatch between the goals and instruments of the EU’s policy toward Ukraine. The EU seems to be missing the point in its relations with Kiev.

  • Merkel’s Refugee Mission

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Thursday, November 05, 2015 4

    The German chancellor is not only trying to rescue refugees. She is also trying to rescue the European Union from self-denial and self-destruction.

  • Judy Asks: Can Democracy Be Rescued in Turkey?

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Wednesday, November 04, 2015 4

    Every week, a selection of leading experts answer a new question from Judy Dempsey on the foreign and security policy challenges shaping Europe’s role in the world.

  • How Will the EU Deal With Postelection Turkey?

    Posted by: Marc Pierini Tuesday, November 03, 2015 3 Русский

    Turkey’s future will depend to a large extent on President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who remains the towering figure of the country’s politics.


About Strategic Europe

Judy Dempsey’s Strategic Europe offers insightful analysis, fresh commentary, and concrete policy recommendations from some of Europe’s keenest international affairs observers.

Subscribe Today

Sign up to receive Judy Dempsey's Strategic Europe updates in your inbox! Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Sign up to receive Strategic Europe updates in your inbox!
Carnegie Europe
Carnegie Europe Rue du Congrès, 15 1000 Brussels, Belgium Phone: +32 2 735 56 50 Fax: +32 2736 6222
Please note...

You are leaving the Carnegie–Tsinghua Center for Global Policy's website and entering another Carnegie global site.


您离开卡内基 - 清华全球政策中心网站,进入另一个卡内基全球网站。