How Russia Is Losing Germany

Merkel; Putin,Merkel; Putin,Merkel; Putin,Merkel; Putin
Posted by: 4 Print Page

The German government is facing one of its most serious foreign policy crises since the collapse of the Berlin Wall nearly a quarter of a century ago. After investing much political, economic, and diplomatic capital in its relations with Russia, Germany is coming to realize that many of those efforts may have been squandered.

Over the past several weeks, when prodemocracy demonstrators in Ukraine ousted president Viktor Yanukoych and Russian President Vladimir Putin invaded Crimea, Berlin consistently pursued a diplomatic track with Moscow.

Frank-Walter Steinmeier, the German foreign minister, is a firm believer in Ostpolitik, the Eastern approach that has underpinned the German-Russian relationship for decades. During recent talks with his Russian counterpart Sergei Lavrov, Steinmeier had one goal in mind: to deescalate the crisis. It was a blow to him when the regional parliament in Crimea announced, with Russian backing, that it would hold a referendum on the peninsula’s status on March 16.

Both Steinmeier and German Chancellor Angela Merkel had also hoped that Russia would stick to its word and give an international “contact group” a chance to establish some kind of dialogue between Moscow and the provisional government in Kiev.

But the Kremlin has made it clear that it has no intentions of talking to Ukraine’s interim leaders. Berlin has been forced to conclude that for the moment, Russia is simply not willing to deescalate and negotiate. Instead, Moscow is set on establishing facts on the ground in Crimea. That is a bitter blow for German diplomacy.

Efforts by the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) also came to naught. Even though Russia is a leading member of the OSCE, it has never been able to bend the organization to its will. Moscow loathes the OSCE’s monitoring of elections and its stance on the freedom of the media. In the current crisis, unarmed OSCE monitors were prevented by force from entering Crimea.

In the longer term, Russia’s rejection of Germany’s diplomatic efforts spells bad news for Russia itself: Moscow risks losing one of its most important allies in Europe.

Those allies are already few and far between. Putin’s close friend former Italian prime minister Silvio Berlusconi has left Italy’s political stage. François Hollande, the French president, has few bonds with the Kremlin apart from a lucrative French defense contract. Barring one or two staunch supporters of Russia, such as Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, Russia risks being completely isolated in Europe.

Russia should not underestimate what losing Germany as an ally could mean. Putin’s rejection of Germany’s diplomatic overtures could precipitate the end of Steinmeier’s long-held belief in Ostpolitik. That would have tremendous consequences for Germany’s relations not only with Russia but also with Ukraine, Belarus, Moldova, and Georgia.

By dismissing Germany’s diplomatic efforts, Russia could be encouraging Germany to take a much more considered look at the geopolitical and security concerns of Poland, the Baltic states, and indeed Ukraine—countries that are now deeply afraid of Russia.

Indeed, Steinmeier’s brief visit to the Baltic states on March 11 was about more than symbolism. The last thing Berlin wants is instability in the region or a backlash against these countries’ ethnic Russian minorities that could provoke Russia in any way. Steinmeier sought to reassure the leaders of the Baltic states that they could count on the EU’s—and Germany’s—solidarity.

“We are not going to abandon Estonia and the Baltic states,” the German foreign minister said after his talks in Tallinn. “This isn’t a problem for Estonia or the Baltic states. This is a common problem for the EU and NATO.” That is a real shift in language. Until recently, NATO had figured low on Berlin’s radar screen.

A day later, Merkel flew to Warsaw to hold talks with Donald Tusk, the Polish prime minister. Until recently, the Poles had made every effort to put their relations with Russia on a more predictable and pragmatic basis. The crisis in Ukraine has changed that.

Poland and its Baltic neighbors do not just want promises of respect for their territorial integrity. They are also anxious for greater security guarantees and increased support from NATO allies and other EU countries.

Merkel is now in the unenviable position of having to decide whether to impose sanctions on Russia. Her government cannot be faulted for having tried diplomacy. But Berlin has now exhausted that track.

One thing is clear: sanctions would be the nail in the coffin for Ostpolitik. Then, Germany could finally begin to pull the EU together around a long-overdue new policy toward Russia and Europe’s Eastern neighborhood.



Comments (4)

  • K Bledowski
    Indeed, Germany is key to steering the EU in the direction of a unified and cogent action. Germany on paper looks to be the lowest common denominator for EU defense and security policy. The strength of EU's response to the Ukraine crisis lies in the position of Berlin.
    Reply to this post

    Close Panel
  • Robintel
    I hope Germany really comes to its senses and restores the leadership granted to it by its economic might and I really hope that Germany will keep its EU friends closer than Russia in a fashion never seen before.

    A stronger EU means a stronger Germany, and the other way around so for Germany to prevail, EU security and peace must prevail.

    This cannot happen with Russian troops preparing to invade Ukraine and Moldova.
    Reply to this post

    Close Panel
  • Retired US Army
    Germany has become extremely weak militarily. Using world bank figures in 2009 it was spending only 1.4% of GDP on defense and by 2011 that had declined to 1.3%. France spends as a percentage of GDP about 2.3%, the USA about 4.6%, and Russia about 4.1%. Germany is all talk and Putin knows it.
    Reply to this post

    Close Panel
  • Karl
    German business says no to sanctions. They have said this publicly. Neither are the german people too keen either to get on the bandwagon. It would be an extremely foolish government to ignore them. They have the most to loose and cannot be expected to pick up the bill every time just to keep their neighbors and the US happy. They simply will not do this regardless of all the hot words. Will the US pay? No. Will Poland pay (or give up some of its 108billion euros from 2012-2020)? No. Will the France pay? No. Will the UK pay? No. The Germans will do the strict minimum, and leave any other bill to their neighbors. It's simply, pay up or shut up.
    Reply to this post

    Close Panel

Subscribe Today

Sign up to receive Judy Dempsey's Strategic Europe updates in your inbox! Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Sign up to receive Strategic Europe updates in your inbox!
Carnegie Europe
Carnegie Europe Rue du Congrès, 15 1000 Brussels, Belgium Phone: +32 2 735 56 50 Fax: +32 2736 6222
Please note...

You are leaving the Carnegie–Tsinghua Center for Global Policy's website and entering another Carnegie global site.


您离开卡内基 - 清华全球政策中心网站,进入另一个卡内基全球网站。