Steinmeier’s YouTube Hit

Posted by: 8 Print Page

On the evening of May 19, Frank-Walter Steinmeier took to the stump—not in Ukraine, where presidential elections will be held on May 25, but on Alexanderplatz, a big, ugly concrete square in eastern Berlin. Germany’s foreign minister was campaigning for the European Parliament elections, which in Germany will also take place on May 25.

Over the past three months, Steinmeier has spent most of his time trying to find a diplomatic way out of the Ukraine crisis. Whatever his critics think of his efforts and dealings with Russia, Steinmeier’s speech at the election rally revealed a side to him rarely seen in public: anger.

Some of those attending the rally carried posters with the words “Stop the Nazis in Ukraine!”—a favorite characterization by Russia’s state media of Ukraine’s interim government. Other demonstrators shouted and held up placards that called Steinmeier a warmonger. Still others had posters that read “EU out, NATO out!”—as if NATO or indeed the EU were going to send troops to Ukraine.

Steinmeier was having none of it. He roared down from the podium: “You should consider who the real warmongers are here: those who call an entire society fascist; those who push for war, who push for conflict!”

There was some applause but also more heckling and whistles. Steinmeier became angrier. “Because we want peace, we can’t let you have it easy,” he shouted. “The world doesn’t just consist of peace angels on the one side and evildoers on the other. Unfortunately, the world is more complicated,” he added. Steinmeier went on to defend the EU with a fierce conviction.

It is not only the German public that shows a surprising amount of sympathy for Russia and an equal amount of hostility toward Ukraine, the EU, and NATO. Nor is this phenomenon limited to the left wing. Throughout Europe, there are nationalist, populist parties, many of which have become sympathetic toward Russian President Vladimir Putin, that could make big gains in the European Parliament elections.

Several of these parties admire Putin’s Russia, an accolade that eluded former Soviet leaders, despite their attempts to gain an ideological foothold in Western Europe through their proxy Communist parties.

Many nationalist and populist parties in Europe see Russia under Putin as a country of peace and a defender against moral decay. To them, Russia is the alternative to what they see as U.S. hegemony and European spinelessness. They ignore Putin’s annexation of Crimea, his meddling in Eastern Ukraine, and his erosion of civil liberties.

Such rhetoric has resonance among voters, if the opinion polls are to be believed. These fringe parties have something in common with Russia: a fear of globalization, a fear of the “other,” and a fear of the open societies that the West stands for.

This fear of globalization includes hatred of the social media that an increasing number of governments try to curb. An exposure to different languages and cultures, brought about by mobility or immigration, can also be threatening for those seeking comfort in certainty and predictability.

Yet, despite calls by Europe’s nationalist parties for governments to put their own countries and citizens first, Europe is part of that globalization. No EU country can go it alone by building fortress walls around itself.

Globalization has provided Southern and Eastern Europe with an invaluable safety valve. The free movement of people enshrined in the EU treaties has allowed young Europeans to find work and opportunities. Globalization also inspires and empowers civil society in many parts of the world.

Yet in Europe, mainstream parties often pander to the nationalist parties instead of defending European values. Britain’s Prime Minister David Cameron has been hypocritical about Poles and other Eastern Europeans who came to work in Britain after the EU’s 2004 eastern enlargement. Incidentally, Cameron hasn’t dared to criticize the presence of immensely rich Russians living in London.

If nationalist and populist parties do make big gains in this week’s European Parliament elections, one reason will be that mainstream politicians did not do enough to stand up for an open Europe. They also need to make much more of an effort to explain the complexities of the modern, globalized world.

Passion and even an occasional outburst of anger can help, as Frank-Walter Steinmeier could tell his colleagues after his campaign speech in Berlin. The video of his performance became a huge hit on YouTube, with over 1.2 million views in just three days.



Comments (8)

  • Tazzz
    You say: "It is not only the German public that shows a surprising amount of sympathy for Russia and an equal amount of hostility toward Ukraine, the EU, and NATO." How would you prove that??? As to the German public, I see
    more indifference towards Ukraïne, a kind of disinterest as to Putin's machinations - but certainly no hostility towards EU and NATO.
    Reply to this post

    Close Panel
  • Denis MacShane
    I did a Berlin meeting on Ukraine 5 May and politely criticised Russia Today and the insistence that anyone who was pro-EU in Kiev was a Nazi putschist. I got booed strongly. There is something not quite right about Germany on this issue and since many west of the Rhine think Mr Steinmeier, like his former boss, Gerhard Schroeder are far to ready to accept the Russian line this is perhaps a wake-up call?
    Reply to this post

    Close Panel
    • Tazzz replies...
      I acknowledge that there is kind of sympathy for Putin, if you take the (left wing) political party "Die Linke" as example, but this ref lects only a micro part of the population and should not be generalized or used as paradigm for the whole country.
  • SteveK9
    It's good to see there is actually some debate in Germany. Instead of the monochromatic Russia/Putin bashing by the Dempsey's of the World.
    Reply to this post

    Close Panel
    • Klas replies...
      Too bad Dempsey dont see that, a warmonger herself I guess.
    • GP replies...
      Unfortunately my experience as a frequent visitor in Germany is the opposite. Leaflets are being handed out on old-town squares showing alleged nazis in Ukraine and attacking sanctions on Russia.
  • Cristina Gallach
    Excellent piece, Judy!
    Reply to this post

    Close Panel
  • John
    Steinmeier showed real passion today in defense of modernity. I don't agree with some SPD ideas on international politics, but agree with him on this and appreciate his genuine commitment to positive values in face of clear opposition. Its remarkable how two SPD politicians show the best and worst of modern Germany, with Schroeder showing the worst, and Steinmeier, at least here, showing the best.
    Reply to this post

    Close Panel

Subscribe Today

Sign up to receive Judy Dempsey's Strategic Europe updates in your inbox! Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Sign up to receive Strategic Europe updates in your inbox!
Carnegie Europe
Carnegie Europe Rue du Congrès, 15 1000 Brussels, Belgium Phone: +32 2 735 56 50 Fax: +32 2736 6222
Please note...

You are leaving the Carnegie–Tsinghua Center for Global Policy's website and entering another Carnegie global site.


您离开卡内基 - 清华全球政策中心网站,进入另一个卡内基全球网站。