After the Catalan parliament voted on October 27 to become an independent republic, Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy used the constitution to fire the government in Barcelona, dissolve the parliament, and impose direct rule on the region from Madrid. Catalan President Carles Puigdemont, along with a few ministers, left the country for Belgium. Eight leaders of the pro-independence movement, including Oriol Junqueras, leader of the Esquerra Republicana party, have been detained. A new regional election has been called for December 21.
In the meantime, in Barcelona on October 29, over 300,000 people demonstrated against Catalan independence, according to the estimates provided by the municipal police force. Carnegie Europe asked Javier Solana, the EU’s former foreign policy chief, former secretary general of NATO, and former foreign minister of Spain, about what the future holds for the country.
Judy Dempsey: What is the way forward?
Javier Solana: Well, the election campaign must be launched. The Catalan election will be held on December 21 and there’s very little time to prepare. The electoral lists have to be ready by November 17. Fortunately, all parties represented in the Catalan parliament have announced that they will be participating in this election.
Dempsey: Was Puigdemont’s decision to leave the country a sign of desperation or even cowardice?
Solana: He went to Brussels to avoid the action of the Spanish courts, which some found very difficult to understand, after the Catalan parliament declared independence. Perhaps he was also seeking international support but, if that’s the case, it is clear that he has failed.
Dempsey: What’s the mood like right now?
Solana: As we speak, the mood in Catalonia is a little bit calmer. The speaker of the Catalan parliament was freed on bail after saying she will comply with the constitution. Puigdemont has announced that he wants to participate in the upcoming election, which will be the most important subject in the next few weeks. A very significant development is that pro-independence parties have not agreed to form a joint list for the election. The winning preelectoral coalition of 2015 won’t be repeated. Rajoy’s move to take away the powers of the Catalan institutions was met with some resistance, but by calling elections right away he managed to throw the pro-independence camp off a bit.
Dempsey: Did Rajoy overplay his hand?
Solana: He played his cards in a very intelligent manner. Puigdemont was convinced on October 26 that he should call elections rather than declare independence. But he got scared when he was accused by the radicals of being a traitor. It was at this point that Puigdemont opted for a unilateral declaration of independence. Rajoy decided to step in and called elections immediately.
Dempsey: Now what happens?
Solana: We are entering a preelection process. Independence will not be the only issue. This election should be chiefly about which party or parties will govern Catalonia.
Dempsey: Can Madrid amend the constitution?
Solana: Yes, there could be some constitutional amendments.
Dempsey: For example?
Solana: Maybe along the lines of a more federal state. But Catalonia in Spain already has more autonomy than Bavaria in Germany. Spain is a very decentralized state.
Dempsey: Then how much further can it go?
Solana: Not very much. Catalonia already has its own education system and police. On the other hand, perhaps something could be done about the financial transfers that Catalonia makes to other less developed regions of the country.
Dempsey: What about the role of the EU?
Solana: This is a very delicate matter for the EU. If the objective is to further integrate Europe, the EU cannot support creating more borders. The EU was right to be firm and its position was coherent. It is clear that it is unacceptable for a region to break away without following the rules of the game.
Javier Solana was EU High Representative for Foreign and Security Policy, Secretary-General of NATO, and Foreign Minister of Spain. He is currently president of the ESADE Center for Global Economy and Geopolitics, distinguished fellow at the Brookings Institution, and a member of the World Economic Forum’s Global Agenda Council on Europe.
Comments(6)
"There is (too?) little time to prepare before Catalan elections" . Why such a hurry ? Will Madrid be able to propose beforehand reforms (constitutionnal, legislative or societal) that might soften the mood of pro-independance voters? If not, the vote could only harden present positions and divisions.
All EU countries exclaimed Kosovo as an independent country except Spain ,because they now very well how sensitive is this question.Young people on the streets of Barcelona don t know how bloody is fight to unit country and make independent big state.All support to Rajoy and crack separation movement in the root.
A quite interesting Article, Mrs. DEMSEY. Right, You are, BUT SPAIN does ABSOLUTELY NEED BEING Re-Founded Again: Have another Constitution and Re-Instate New Ways of Governing its TERRITORY: Since the Catalonians didn't want to remain in Spain and did democratically REFUSE, in a Referendum! But The Main-land, federal "Spain" decided to sort-of Colonialize Catalunia! In Western Europe: it ought To RAIZE many Discussions: but, It's BUSINESS AS USUAL, as if Nothing had even happened inside the European Union borders: Nobody bothers about the FREEDOM of Choice of some Peoples, European PEOPLE. It's not, this time tha Fault to Russian who may have sabotaged the Poll scrutiny. Is IT? Why Should the Spaniards refuse Freedom to Catalonians? Is there any founded Explanation to their Premier,'s current Attitude against Independence line Holders? Where are the HARD - LINERS? On what Side ...Both SIDES! Just an Opinion.
An independent Catalonia, in the EU, means effectieve, less borders. An independent Catalonia, also means less conflict and less stress between the peoples of Spain and catalonia, and both can thus strive for they maximum potential. An independent Catalonia is the onlusten wat foreward.
Nothing is scarier than: “On the other hand, perhaps something could be done about the financial transfers that Catalonia makes to other less developed regions of the country.” Is this what the Western civilization has been reduced to, MPS and TINA on steroids? What is next for Spain, dynamic scoring and trickledown economics, free market based education and healtcare? Are we back from Smith, Keynes and Hayek to Rand and Friedman? Nations are constructs which unite people on higher purposes than just money. EU is a construct uniting nation beyond the immediate monetary calculations. Spain was supposed to be a pillar of the EU, an example for the others. It was expected for the UK to seek preferential treatment, based on memories of global hegemon eons ago, hegemon supposed to lead the world in peace, not Munich, phoney war and eventually napkin treaties, followed now by Budapest memorandum. Brexit shattered the very fabric of the EU, and the acrimonious divorce might further affect the future of the EU. Without any doubt the EU doesn’t need new frontiers, more energy wasted on keeping unity instead on focusing on the future challenges. SCO, RCEP, BRI, climate change should be more than enough to keep a united EU busy. CaExit, nobody needs it. Each time the democracy is confused with secession everybody should remember democracy is a two-way street, responsible citizenry, responsible leadership. Both seem to be more and more in short supply.
I find it a very interesting interview. Nevertheless there are some points to discuss. For example, it in not true that Spain is so decentralized. The Spanish Constitution always reserve a voice and a power on the Central institutions. For example, regarding education or local administration the State has always a word and some powers; in Scotland no.
Comment Policy
Comments that include profanity, personal attacks, or other inappropriate material will be removed. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, steps will be taken to block users who violate any of the posting standards, terms of use, privacy policies, or any other policies governing this site. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.